DoSayGive's Baby Doll Review

DoSayGive’s Baby Doll Review


“What is the best baby doll for my little girl?” I get asked this question all the time so I am finally sharing my favorite baby doll brands, age recommendations, and accessories for a child’s first baby doll – just in time for Christmas!

Having four girls we know a thing about baby dolls! For a first doll my advice is to choose one doll that can last for several years. The stuffed animal dolls are cute but in my experience babies prefer more lifelike dolls. Here are three of my favorites:

Corolle Mon Premier Baby 12″ Doll

Made in France, Corolle has been a trusted doll brand for years. And they are quite affordable. Corolle has dolls for 9 months and 2 years but I say skip those and just buy the “Mon Premier” doll recommended for age 18 months+. (Perfectly fine to give at 12 months, in my opinion.) The soft body makes her easy to tote around for toddlers but will be enjoyed for several years or more. Several versions of the Mon Premier doll can be found on Amazon and in boutiques.

She’s holding the Corolle doll.

Rosalina 10″ Doll

I found this precious doll with the smocked dress and bonnet at Layette Dallas. The 10″ size is a bit smaller than the Corolle so perfect if you are wanting to give a doll to a 6-12 month old that she will enjoy for years to come. Made in Spain, Rosalina dolls also have a soft body which makes it easy for little hands to hold. You can choose the doll by eye color and purchase a dress separately. And, of course, can order more dresses for future birthdays. Check Rosalina’s website for matching girl dresses! If you order from Layette they can monogram the girl’s name or chosen baby name in the dress. Call to order. They wrap beautifully and ship!

American Girl Bitty Baby

This is a bigger baby doll so not suitable for a one year old in my opinion. More like ages 2 -6. But is is a beautiful doll and holds up very well through the years. I have a friend whose daughter never got into the regular American Girl dolls because she loved “Bitty” so much. There are so many skin type, clothing, and accessory options at American Girl. This diaper bag (ours is the older version) has been worth the money. American Girl accessories are so well made and last. Pottery Barn Kids also has a great diaper bag set (see below).

Tip: order AG items earlier in the holiday season because they tend to go on backorder. And they rarely go on sale. And if you want a less expensive option like Bitty, Pottery Barn Kids’ GOTZ baby dolls are similar. If you can use one of PB Kids’ frequent discount codes it is a much better price!

Baby Doll Accessories

Heed my warning: it’s easy to go overboard with accessories because they are so cute! But I’ve found my children tend to bond with toys – and treat them more carefully – if they aren’t drowning in them. So buy one diaper bag set with a few accessorie or one bottle or dish and spoon for a stocking. Corolle, Adora (sold at fine toy stores), and Pottery Barn Kids are some of my favorite accessory brands.

If you are looking to purchase a bigger baby doll accessory I would say a stroller gets more use than a baby bed or changing table or even baby carrier, especially when it comes to ages 1-3. I am considering getting this pram for Louise! I gathered some of my favorite strollers and accessory ideas here:

American Girl Bitty Baby Doll
Shop Now
Rosalina Baby Doll
Shop Now
Corolle Mon Premier Baby Doll
Shop Now
Götz Baby Doll
Shop Now
Madame Alexander Baby Huggums
Shop Now
Baby Alive Real As Can Be Baby
Shop Now
Umbrella Doll Stroller
Shop Now
Badger Basket 3-in-1 Doll Pram, Carrier, and Stroller
Shop Now
Corolle Mon Premier Stroller
Shop Now
Summer Meadow Doll Pram
Shop Now
Hape Baby Doll Stroller
Shop Now
Adora Foldable Umbrella Play Stroller
Shop Now
Gray Stars Pram Doll Stroller
Shop Now
Janod Doll Stroller
Shop Now
Little Tikes Classic Doll Buggy
Shop Now
Honestly Cute Fold Up Stroller
Shop Now
Corolle Mon Premier Mealtime Toy Set
Shop Now
Jenny Lind Doll Bed
Shop Now
Baby Doll High Chair
Shop Now
Baby Doll Diaper Bag
Shop Now

Hope this post helps! Let me know if you want to see a post on dolls for older girls or doll house reviews!

Also, DoSayGive’s Holiday Gift Guide is launching next week. Subscribe here to get first notice!


Shop The Post
What do you think?
Leave a Comment

12 thoughts on “DoSayGive’s Baby Doll Review

  1. My two year old has really ‘discovered’ her baby dolls lately and it has been so much fun.

    I love the pram-style strollers. This past year (when my daughter was newly 1), Santa brought Little Tikes Classic Doll Buggy. I highly recommend it for toddlers because it’s so sturdy! Not tippy, and can hold their weight when they inevitably decide to climb in ?

  2. I love Baby Stella for 1 year olds. Cute magnetic pacifier and soft accessories.

    Would love to see posts on dolls for older girls!

  3. Thanks! I Love this post! Another great Doll is the Madame Alexander Huggums! The Corolle Doll is the most loved in our house by my girls though, for sure!

    Would love to see a post for dolls for older girls! My girls are 3 and 4 and we are just getting ready to get into the bigger dolls! ?

  4. All three of my daughters were given a Madame Alexander Huggums doll at birth (it sort of became a tradition started by my mother-in-law). They are perfect for young children…soft to the touch and small enough to carry. My oldest, who is 21, took hers to college with her. It is definitely a special momento of her childhood.

  5. Madam Alexander Victoria. Both of my daughter and granddaughters loved this doll. It comes in two sizes wearing pretty gowns.

  6. Do the 10 inch Rosalina doll clothes and bonnet fit on the Carolle 12 inch doll? I would love to buy my daughter the Carolle doll but add clothes made by Rosalina. Thank you!

  7. Aww. I wish my girls loved dolls more when they were little. This post reminds me of the doll my sisters and I loved when we were little. Her name was Miss Smiley and she was most like the bitty babies but had a little Mohawk of hair. {I’m pretty sure my Grandmother got her at a garage sale.} She had plastic arms, legs, and head and a good sized soft body perfect for carrying around on your hip. We played and played with her. Through the years the little bit of hair she had got cut off and she was bald, but we didn’t care. One day my mom took Miss Smiley to a doll maker to get her a wig. But with a full head of hair, she just wasn’t the same and we hardly ever played with her again. 🙂

  8. Do you think the 18+ month Corelle dolls would be ok for an 8 month old? Our little will be right at 8 months for Christmas.